[Content Note: Gun violence, poisoning, fire, torture, beheading, self-mutilation, ethnic stereotype (German), child abuse. This also contains extensive spoilers for episode 4.]
Is that a plot hole?
Our story opens in Boston Harbor, December 16 1773. Blah blah, men in tights destroying the heck out of crates. Other men, including Ichabod, are stealthily stealing into a building via mega-stealth. The leader informs Ichabod that “Colonel Washington’s orders were clear! Bring back the crate… and you!” (Now, if you are wondering what George Washington is doing ordering around anyone before he’s even had time to get mad about the not-yet passed Intolerable Acts, well, that WILL BE EXPLAINED!)
They surprise a red-coated soldier. The stealthy commander steps forward and says “IN THE NAME OF THE VIRGINIA MILITIA! We claim this cargo!”( Now, if you are wondering what the Virginia militia are doing in Massachusetts, and considering looking it up in your college history text, well, that WILL BE EXPLAINED!)
The officer responds: Praying in German! To somebody evil in German! (Now, if you are thinking, “But didn’t the Hessians arrive in 1776?” and pondering writing a sternly worded letter to your former history professor, well, THAT WILL BE EXPLAINED! –ish.)
There is a big explosion, which segues to Ichabod, in the present, sitting in a car talking about his wife and true love. A female voice thanks his for putting it all into perspective. Ho ho ho! Ichabod is not just remembering his wife, he is counseling the OnStar person! LOL forever briefly!
Abbie and Captain Orlando “Grumpy” Jones are discussing Jenny’s escape. Abbie asks for more time to investigate. Captain “Grumpy” is wondering what Ichabod said to set Jenny off.
Ichabod: I merely informed her of a bunch of gruesome, possibly paranormal shit. PS She’s actually totally sane.
Captain Grumpy: “You’re the last person I want vouching for sanity.”
Abbie: BACK TO THE POINT—I can catch my sister.
Captain Grumpy is grumpy, but gives them 12 hours. Switch to Jenny at a bar. Bartender has been keeping something for her. They converse. Jenny: Something something, remember when I told you I’d go straight to hell? Switch to a piano lesson (whut.) A blond white man is supervising a student. He gets a call from a deep voiced person. They converse. Deep Voice: Something something, she has escaped, find her, something something thirty-sevens. Switch to the bar. Piano Guy shows up with bonus blond Menacing Dudes. The Bartender is there. They converse.
Piano Guy: Jennifer Mills?
Bartender (totally lying): Nope!
Piano Guy: You are totally lying.
Bartender: *whips out +4 Stereotypical Bartender Shotgun of Intimidation *
Piano Guy/Menacing Dudes: *pin Bartender to billiard table, evoke confession, commit grotesque murder.* “Hell will come to us.”
Switch to Abbie and Ichabod. They are trying to find Jenny and quarreling. Abbie reveals that her father left when she and Jenny were young, their mother had a nervous breakdown and was hospitalized, she and Jenny were put in foster care. Ichabod suggests they go see Jenny’s last foster parents. Switch to Jenny in the +6 Stereotypical Washroom of Spectacular Ick, rummaging through a bag. She pulls out some documents, and newspaper article about Abbie, and a gun. (This, btw, is exactly how I pack.) She heads to the bar but whoooops! The police are there investigating the bartender’s murder. His body has been pinned to the wall, while his head is on the Billiard table. Captain Orlando “Grumpy” Jones is discussing the murder with Abbie’s ex, Detective “Vaguely Douchey” Nicholas Gonzales.
Detective Vaguely Douchey: We have this solved. Smirk. Head chopped off, must be the same as the murder of Sherriff Kindly. Smirk smirk.
Captain Grumpy: Here are your obvious mistakes. Here are all the ways these killings differ. Here is your ass on a platter.
Detective Vaguely Douchey: Where did my smirk go?
Switch to: Jennie and Ichabod visit Jenny’s former foster mom.
Former Mom: Troubled kids need “discipline and order.” I am obviously a neglectful, abusive, shitty person who should never have foster kids. I’m terrible.
Abbie: You’re doing a shitty job and abusing the kids in your care. You had better tell me about my sister’s possible whereabouts.
Former Mom: I’m terrible.
Ichabod: Leftenant!
Abbie: “I will rain legal brimstone down on you until it makes God jealous.”
Former Mom: I’ll help. You’re terrible.
Abbie: You’re still in deep shit.
Former Mom: Cutting remark, because I’m terrible.
Abbie and Ichabod have discovered that Jenny used to go visit a Cabin in the Woods, because Joss Whedon Sherrif Kindly. After a brief flirtation/lockpicking session (Ichabod: “Imagine the delinquency we could perpetrate if we really put our minds together….” = HAWT!) they discover that Sherriff Corbin had a huge painting of General Washington on the wall. Then Jenny appears in a most dramatic fashion!
Jenny: boo! I’ve got a gun!
Abbie: I’ve got a gun!
Ichabod: This is awkward! Let’s go to an ad.
Open Wide...
Shut Up!